Novel Cancer Drug Test May Results in Safer and More Effective Clinical Trials

A group of scientists from Hamburg may have taken a big step towards more effective cancer drug development. Dr Ilona Schonn, Director of Cell Culture Research at Indivumed GmbH, a company specialized in the analysis and procurement of highly standardized tissue samples and data of tumor patients, told the audience at Europe’s largest cancer congress, the joint 15th European CanCer Organisation (ECCO) and 34th European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) Multidisciplinary Congress, September 20 – 24 in Berlin, Germany, that they had developed a preclinical drug test platform that would enable researchers to analyze tumor tissue for individual patient drug responses on the molecular level.

To date most tests for drug metabolism and toxicity testing have used tissue slices of normal organs like liver, kidney and lung. The new test was created specifically for oncology drug testing and uses tumor tissues from colorectal and lung cancer patients.

A major problem of drug development at present is the inability to extrapolate response in preclinical cell models to patients. “Approximately 90% of clinical trials fail because the drugs used are too ineffective or too toxic,” explained Dr Schonn. “Not only does this result in unacceptably high costs for drug development, but it also exposes patients to risks from toxicity or simply wastes their time in testing a substance which proves to be ineffective.”

The problem arises from the fact that patients respond individually to drugs. In addition, each tumor consists of a variety of different cancer cells that interact in different ways with the framework of individual non-tumor cells, resulting in highly variable growth behavior and response to drugs. Dr Schonn and her team set out to try to develop a drug test that would eliminate these problems and provide an accurate model of individual patient response.

“Based on freshly cultivated intact tissue from surgically treated cancer patients we are now able to analyze numerous tumors from different patients, to identify differences in drug response between those patients, and to understand variations of response in cell subtypes within one tumor,” said Dr Schonn.

The new test allows scientists to translate findings from commonly used cell lines to a preclinical model which is as close as possible to using the same drug in the clinical setting, thus enabling a better estimate of the number of patients who are likely to respond to the treatment. It also helps to identify biomarkers that can predict drug response for patients entering a clinical trial, allowing researchers to include only those patients whose participation will provide a significant answer to the question being asked.

“Together with all the clinical patient data and several analytical test systems such as signaling pathway analysis, we have been able to characterize individual tumors in more detail. This will improve the understanding of drug effects and treatments, a step forward towards the goal of individualized cancer therapy,” she said. “The test is of particular interest to pharmaceutical companies because it allows the analysis of samples from meaningful number of patients with different tumors in a short period of time, and can, therefore, accelerate progression of a potential new treatment to clinical trials.”

In addition, it can help gain more knowledge about the mode of action of a new compound in patients, and identify optimal disease areas, for example tumors with particular mutations or over-expression of target receptors, and dosage.

To date the test has only been validated in colon, non-small cell lung (NSCLC), and breast cancer tumors but there is no reason to think that it would not be equally accurate in other solid tumor types, the scientists say.

“Because the test allows us to maintain the complex environment of the primary cancer tumor, we believe that it holds out great promise for the quick and effective elucidation of response to anticancer drugs,” said Dr Schonn. “We hope to be able to apply it to a growing number of drugs emerging from the labs of pharmaceutical companies to help to shorten development time and to make clinical trials both more efficient and safer for patients.”

The test can analyze numerous tumors from different patients, identify the patients’ diverse reactions to the test compounds and elucidate their varying effects on cell subtypes within the same tumor. Says Prof Dr Hartmut Juhl, CEO and founder of Indivumed. “In the long run, our test paves the way to personalized medicine, because it helps to understand and to embrace the individual reactions of the patients to a certain therapy.”

For more information:

• Abstract no: 1013, Basic Science/Translational Research poster discussion, Wednesday 17.00 – 18.00 hrs CEST (Hall 14.2)